SARBANES-OXLEY ACT OF 2002

Sarbanes-Oxley § 304

Forfeiture of CEO and CFO Bonuses (Clawback)

STATUTORY BENCHMARKS
  • Statutory provision: Sarbanes-Oxley § 304 under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002.
  • Scienter standard: No Personal Misconduct Required for Issuer Misconduct.
  • Standard statutory remedies: Mandatory reimbursement of executive incentive compensation and stock sale profits to the company.

STATUTORY ELEMENTS & LEGAL STANDARDS

SARBANES-OXLEY ACT OF 2002
Legal Dimension Statutory Standard & Enforcement Criteria
Statutory Scope Requires CEOs and CFOs of issuers that restate financials due to material noncompliance as a result of misconduct to reimburse the issuer for bonuses, incentive pay, and equity profits received during the 12-month period following the filing.
Required Elements of Proof
  1. Accounting restatement required due to material noncompliance
  2. Misconduct by any person at the issuer
  3. Executive need not have participated in the fraud personally to be subject to clawback
Scienter Burden No Personal Misconduct Required for Issuer Misconduct
Standard Remedies Mandatory reimbursement of executive incentive compensation and stock sale profits to the company.
Jurisdiction United States Federal Law

ENFORCEMENT PRECEDENTS CHARGING SARBANES-OXLEY § 304

4 SELECTED PRECEDENTS
Case Title Status Overstatement (USD) Penalties (USD) Action
Computer Associates: $2.2B '35-Day Month' Revenue Backdating
Routinely kept corporate accounting books open past quarter ends to backdate hundreds of millions in software license sales.
Adjudicated $2.2B $225.0M Case Dossier →
Brocade Communications: Criminal Options Backdating Scheme
CEO Gregory Reyes retroactively selected dates when stock traded at historic lows to grant heavily in-the-money executive stock options.
Adjudicated $150.0M $7.0M Case Dossier →
UnitedHealth Group: Decades-Long Options Backdating and $400M Clawback
Systematically backdated stock option awards to historical quarterly trading lows, avoiding compensation expense.
Settled, neither admitted nor denied $1.5B $400.0M Case Dossier →
Comverse Technology: Phantom Employee Stock Options Backdating & Slush Fund
Executives systematically backdated employee stock options to historic price lows and created a secret slush fund of options granted under fictitious employee names.
Adjudicated $150.0M $53.0M Case Dossier →