Editorial & Research Methodology
The Corporate Fraud Library is constructed upon strict evidentiary standards. This page explains our data extraction protocols, entity disambiguation rules, 36-scheme classification framework, and human editorial review process.
- Primary Source Discipline: Every case, scheme classification, and penalty figure is anchored to an official regulatory order, docket, or statutory filing.
- Strict Editorial Neutrality: Factual findings follow regulator orders; unresolved complaints are explicitly badged as 'Alleged'.
- Editorial & Automation Oversight: Automated normalization scripts organize filings; human editors review schema accuracy and source citations.
- Currency Normalization: International penalties and overstatements are converted to USD at the action date using historical reference exchange rates while preserving original currency values.
1. Primary Source Extraction
We do not rely on unverified blogs or encyclopedia summaries. Records indexed across our 125 canonical cases originate from official government repositories and judicial archives: SEC Accounting and Auditing Enforcement Releases (AAERs), SEC Litigation Releases, DOJ Criminal Division press releases and indictments, federal court dockets (CourtListener/RECAP), PCAOB settled disciplinary orders, and international financial supervisory tribunals (including the UK FRC, FCA, SFO, German BaFin, and Japanese SESC). See our complete Primary Sources Registry.
2. Entity Resolution & Relational Architecture
Issuers, individual officers, audit firms, and regulatory authorities are matched deterministically using statutory identifiers: SEC Central Index Key (CIK) numbers, Legal Entity Identifiers (LEI), standardized legal names, and historical alias mappings. Ambiguous entities are reviewed before publication so multi-jurisdictional sanctions link cleanly to the right legal party.
3. 36-Scheme Taxonomy Classification
Cases are mapped to our 36-scheme accounting fraud taxonomy spanning five major families (Revenue Recognition, Expenses & Reserves, Balance Sheet & Assets, Disclosure & Controls, and Auditor Conduct). Every scheme assignment pairs deterministic accounting rules with supporting evidence quotes drawn from the underlying regulatory findings.
4. Automation & Editorial Review Disclosure
Building a cross-border relational archive uses structured automation pipelines alongside editorial oversight:
- Automated Data Engineering: Software scripts compute aggregate totals, cross-index scheme relationships, convert foreign currency amounts to historical USD equivalents, and validate schema integrity across JSON/CSV exports.
- Human Editorial Governance: Case summaries, forensic journal entry reconstructions, legal posture designations, and long-form research articles are authored, structured, and checked for accuracy by the Corporate Fraud Library Editorial Team.
5. Legal Status Badging
To preserve legal accuracy and fairness, every enforcement dossier explicitly displays its procedural posture:
- Alleged: Used for civil complaints or pending criminal indictments prior to final adjudication or settlement.
- Settled, neither admitted nor denied: Used for administrative consent orders where respondents agreed to sanctions without admitting or denying factual findings.
- Adjudicated: Used following a jury verdict, bench ruling, guilty plea, or formal administrative finding of liability.
6. Corrections & Verification
Whenever primary regulatory dockets are amended or a user identifies a numerical or factual discrepancy, verified updates are published promptly and documented on our Corrections Log.