Adjudicated US NYSE

Computer Associates: $2.2B '35-Day Month' Revenue Backdating

Routinely kept corporate accounting books open past quarter ends to backdate hundreds of millions in software license sales.

CASE PROFILE & BENCHMARKS
  • Target Issuer: Computer Associates International, Inc. (US).
  • Fraud Period: January 1, 2004 to December 31, 2006.
  • Reported Overstatement: $2.2B.
  • Total Fines & Penalties: $225.0M.
  • Maximum Incarceration: No prison sentence.
  • Independent Auditor: KPMG LLP.
  • Primary Schemes: premature recognition.
  • Enforcement Status: ADJUDICATED (admitted).
OVERSTATEMENT $2.2B USD reported
TOTAL PENALTIES $225.0M Civil & disgorgement
PRISON TIME None No prison sentence
FIRST ACTION September 20, 2006 Initial proceeding
DETECTION METHOD Regulatory Enforcement & Forensic Audit Discovery source
PRIMARY REGULATOR U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission US

FORENSIC ACCOUNTING AUTOPSY & MECHANICS

HOW IT WAS DONE
Forensic Aspect Regulatory Record & Ledger Mechanics
Accounting Mechanics In settled proceedings with admissions, the regulator found that The company manipulated its accounting records by executing schemes under premature-recognition. Financial reports filed with market regulators contained material misstatements that distorted true financial condition.
Evidentiary Finding Routinely kept corporate accounting books open past quarter ends to backdate hundreds of millions in software license sales.
Mechanism Definition Accelerating the recording of revenue into the current period prior to meeting all recognition criteria, such as holding books open past quarter-end.
Affected Accounts Accounts Receivable (Asset) • Revenue (Income Statement) • Contract Asset / Unearned Revenue
Issuer Corporate Context Enterprise software company that backdated hundreds of millions of dollars in software contracts using a '35-day month' cutoff practice.
Independent Auditor KPMG LLP : Big Four accounting network penalized for audit failures in Carillion, Xerox, and the PCAOB inspection leak scandal.
Primary Discovery Method Regulatory Enforcement & Forensic Audit

ILLUSTRATIVE GENERAL LEDGER MECHANICS (PREMATURE REVENUE RECOGNITION)

IMPROPER VS. GAAP/IFRS TREATMENT
Improper Booked Entry Proper GAAP / IFRS Treatment Accounting Distortion & Mechanism
DR: Accounts Receivable: $8,000,000
CR: Product Revenue: $8,000,000
DR: Cash / AR (in subsequent period): $8,000,000
CR: Deferred Revenue (until actual shipment/service in Q2): $8,000,000
Keeping the shipping log or accounting period open past midnight of the quarter close date (e.g. Month 36 or the 35-day month) to pull forward future sales.

FINANCIAL STATEMENT & RATIO DISTORTIONS

QUANTITATIVE SCREENING SIGNALS
Financial Metric / Ratio Distortion Direction Forensic Explanation
Quarterly Revenue Cyclicality Extreme end-of-quarter spikes The first month of each fiscal quarter experiences abnormally depressed sales because transactions were dragged into the prior quarter.
Taxonomy Applicable Scheme Classifications
Correlated Schemes

CHARGED RESPONDENTS & OUTCOMES

1 NAMED PARTIES
Respondent Role Disposition & Judicial Outcome Prison Civil Penalty O&D Bar
Computer Associates International, Inc. ISSUER Enforcement order and financial sanctions imposed. None $225.0M No

RED FLAGS OBSERVED PRIOR TO DISCOVERY

1 EARLY WARNING INDICATORS
Red Flag Indicator Period Observed Observed Forensic Anomaly Diagnostic View
CASH FLOW TO NET INCOME DIVERGENCE 2004 Operating cash flow severely diverged from reported earnings Inspect Metric →

ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS & PRIMARY DOCKETS

PRIMARY SOURCE CITATIONS
Filing Date Type & Docket ID Enforcement Order & Regulatory Findings Disposition Primary Record
September 20, 2006
aaer
ENF-2004-computer-associates
Enforcement Action: Computer Associates: $2.2B '35-Day Month' Revenue Backdating
Routinely kept corporate accounting books open past quarter ends to backdate hundreds of millions in software license sales.
Securities & Corporate Law Compliance
Source: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission: Accounting and Auditing Enforcement Releases (AAER) • Official Jurisdiction: US
admitted Docket Record ↗

TIMELINE OF EVENTS

2 CHRONOLOGICAL MILESTONES
Date Event Category Chronological Forensic Milestone
June 1, 2004 MISSTATEMENT Material accounting irregularities commenced.
September 20, 2006 ENFORCEMENT Regulators commenced formal proceedings.