SEC RULES OF PRACTICE
SEC Rule of Practice 102(e)
Suspension and Debarment of Accountants and Auditors
STATUTORY BENCHMARKS
- Statutory provision: SEC Rule of Practice 102(e) under the SEC Rules of Practice.
- Scienter standard: Improper Professional Conduct (Negligence or Intent).
- Standard statutory remedies: Permanent or multi-year practice suspensions, prohibition from auditing public company filings.
STATUTORY ELEMENTS & LEGAL STANDARDS
SEC RULES OF PRACTICE| Legal Dimension | Statutory Standard & Enforcement Criteria |
|---|---|
| Statutory Scope | Authorizes the Commission to censure or deny, temporarily or permanently, the privilege of appearing or practicing before the Commission to accountants who engage in improper professional conduct or lack character and integrity. |
| Required Elements of Proof |
|
| Scienter Burden | Improper Professional Conduct (Negligence or Intent) |
| Standard Remedies | Permanent or multi-year practice suspensions, prohibition from auditing public company filings. |
| Jurisdiction | United States Federal Law |
ENFORCEMENT PRECEDENTS CHARGING SEC RULE OF PRACTICE 102(E)
10 SELECTED PRECEDENTS| Case Title | Status | Overstatement (USD) | Penalties (USD) | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WorldCom: $11B Operating Expense Capitalization Fraud WorldCom falsely classified over $3.8 billion in routine line costs as long-term capital expenditures and improperly released reserve cushions, transforming massive operational losses into billions in fraudulent pre-tax earnings. | Adjudicated | $11.0B | $750.0M | Case Dossier → |
| Enron Corp.: Off-Balance-Sheet SPEs and Mark-to-Model Fabrication Enron used hundreds of unconsolidated special purpose entities (SPEs) funded with Enron stock to hide debt, scrub merchant investment losses, and book billions in mark-to-model paper gains. | Adjudicated | $1.2B | $23.8M | Case Dossier → |
| Wirecard AG: 1.9 Billion Euro Fictitious Cash Fraud German DAX-30 payments firm Wirecard fabricated one quarter of its consolidated balance sheet (1.9 billion euros), falsely claiming the cash was held in trustee escrow accounts in the Philippines. | Adjudicated | $2.1B | $0 | Case Dossier → |
| Satyam Computer Services: $1B Fabricated Cash and Ghost Employees Satyam Chairman B. Ramalinga Raju confessed that 94% of the company's reported cash balance (over $1 billion) was entirely fictitious, inflated by 7,561 fake invoices and non-existent interest income. | Adjudicated | $1.0B | $290.0M | Case Dossier → |
| Carillion plc: Aggressive Contract Revenue and Going-Concern Concealment UK government contractor Carillion concealed catastrophic construction project losses, booking expected future claims as current revenue while masking £1.5B in debt using supply chain financing. | Adjudicated | $1.4B | $27.0M | Case Dossier → |
| ZZZZ Best: $100M Fictitious Building Restoration Contracts and Staged Site Tours Teenage founder Barry Minkow built ZZZZ Best into a $300M public carpet cleaning company on fictitious multi-million-dollar insurance restoration contracts, staging elaborate fake building walkthroughs for Ernst & Whinney auditors. | Adjudicated | $100.0M | $26.0M | Case Dossier → |
| Bre-X Minerals: $6B Busang Gold Reserve Salting and Exploration Fraud Bre-X claimed to discover the richest gold deposit on Earth at Busang, Indonesia, inflating its stock to $6B before independent drill testing proved drill cores had been salted with gold river dust. | Adjudicated | $6.0B | $0 | Case Dossier → |
| Refco: $430M Hidden Customer Bad-Debt Round-Tripping via Bawag Bank Commodities giant Refco collapsed into bankruptcy two months after its $583M IPO when new executives discovered CEO Phillip Bennett had concealed $430M in trading bad debt through circular loans with Austrian bank Bawag. | Adjudicated | $430.0M | $2.4B | Case Dossier → |
| NMC Health: $4.5B Undisclosed Bilateral Debt and Supply Chain Financing Fraud FTSE 100 healthcare group NMC Health collapsed into administration after Muddy Waters exposed $4.5B in hidden bilateral loans, fake invoices, and off-balance-sheet supplier financing funneled to founder B.R. Shetty's private entities. | Adjudicated | $4.5B | $5.7M | Case Dossier → |
| Peregrine Financial Group: $215M Embezzlement and 20-Year Bank Confirmation Forgery PFG Best founder Russell Wasendorf Sr. siphoned over $215M in customer funds for two decades, intercepting paper audit confirmations using a post office box masquerading as U.S. Bank. | Adjudicated | $215.0M | $215.5M | Case Dossier → |