CALL TEAR-DOWN • FY 2019 / Q1 2020 Update (2020-04-28)
Wirecard AG: Markus Braun Dismissing KPMG Audit Scope Limitation
CEO Markus Braun presented KPMG's special forensic audit as a complete vindication, falsely assuring global institutional investors that no evidence of balance sheet manipulation was found.
EARNINGS CALL FORENSIC PROFILE
- Company: Wirecard AG (FY 2019 / Q1 2020 Update, 2020-04-28).
- Infamous Disclosure: Markus Braun Dismissing KPMG Audit Scope Limitation.
- Public Record: Archival Webcast Broadcast.
CONFERENCE CALL DIALOGUE TRANSCRIPT
ARCHIVAL WEBCAST BROADCAST| Timestamp | Speaker | Verbatim Executive Statement / Exchange |
|---|---|---|
| 04:15 | Markus Braun | "I would like to emphasize that the special investigation conducted by KPMG has fully confirmed the integrity of our reported numbers. KPMG found no evidence whatsoever of accounting manipulation or fictitious revenues in our third-party acquiring business." |
| 08:30 | Markus Braun | "The allegations made by speculative short sellers and certain media outlets regarding our escrow accounts in Asia have been completely addressed. All documentation requested has been verified." |
| 12:10 | Alexander von Knoop | "We reiterate our full-year EBITDA guidance of 1.0 to 1.12 billion euros, demonstrating the extraordinary operational cash generation of the Wirecard ecosystem." |
FORENSIC REALITY & SUBSEQUENT UNRAVELING
EVIDENTIARY AUDIT| Forensic Aspect | Evidentiary Record & Reality |
|---|---|
| Accounting Reality At That Hour | KPMG's actual written audit report released that same morning explicitly stated that KPMG could neither confirm nor rule out that revenues and escrow balances existed. KPMG specifically noted that Wirecard failed to provide direct bank confirmation letters for 1.0 billion euros in Philippine escrow accounts, relying instead on suspicious third-party trustee photocopies. |
| Subsequent Corporate Unraveling | Fifty-eight days later, regular statutory auditor EY formally refused to sign off on the 2019 financial statements after Philippine banks BPI and BDO confirmed that the escrow accounts and certificates were complete forgeries. Wirecard collapsed into insolvency with over 3.2 billion euros in missing funds. |
| Call Participants | Markus Braun (Chief Executive Officer) Alexander von Knoop (Chief Financial Officer) |
| Associated Fraud Case | Wirecard AG: 1.9 Billion Euro Fictitious Cash Fraud German DAX-30 payments firm Wirecard fabricated one quarter of its consolidated balance sheet (1.9 billion euros), falsely claiming the cash was held in trustee escrow accounts in the Philippines.
View Full Case Dossier →
|
ARCHIVED FORENSIC CALL TRANSCRIPTS
HISTORIC EARNINGS CALLS| Company / Issuer | Fiscal Quarter & Date | Transcript View |
|---|---|---|
| Enron Corp. | Q1 2001 • 2001-04-17 | Read Transcript → |
| Luckin Coffee Inc. | Q3 2019 • 2019-11-13 | Read Transcript → |
| WorldCom, Inc. | Q3 2001 • 2001-10-25 | Read Transcript → |