CRIMINOLOGICAL RISK MODEL
Fraud Triangle Risk Assessment Calculator
Diagnostic scoring instrument based on Donald Cressey's classic model and SAS 99 auditing standards to evaluate institutional fraud vulnerability.
FRAUD TRIANGLE BENCHMARKS
- Criminologist Donald Cressey's Fraud Triangle posits that three conditions must co-exist for occupational fraud: Pressure, Opportunity, and Rationalization.
- Auditing standard SAS 99 (AU-C 240) mandates that external auditors systematically evaluate these three pillars during financial statement audits.
- Scores above 70 indicate critical exposure to financial reporting manipulation and management override.
1. HISTORICAL CORPORATE RISK PRESETS
CLICK TO LOAD PRESET| Corporate Profile | Score | Risk Tier | Criminological Drivers & Systemic Vulnerabilities | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Enron Corp (2001) | 96 / 100 | Critical Risk | Crushing stock price pressure, complex SPE unconsolidated vehicles, culture of aggressive greed | |
| WorldCom, Inc. (2002) | 89 / 100 | Severe Risk | E/R line cost targets, CFO override of journal systems, 'we will fix it next quarter' rationalization | |
| Robust Internal Controls | 0 / 100 | Low Risk | Independent board audit committee, segregated ERP controls, zero tolerance whistleblower protection |
2. PRESSURE & INCENTIVE DIAGNOSTIC CRITERIA
0 / 33 POINTS| Pressure Metric | Diagnostic Slider (0 to 6.6 Points) | Score |
|---|---|---|
|
Debt Covenant & Maturity Proximity
Imminent liquidity cliff or loan default | Healthy Cash Reserves Imminent Breach / Liquidity Crisis | 0.0 |
|
Executive Stock & Incentive Comp Concentration
Wealth tied to quarterly EPS targets | Modest Base Salary All Wealth in Unvested Options | 0.0 |
|
Analyst Earnings Consensus Targets
Severe penalties for 1-cent misses | Guidance Provided with Margin Extreme Unrealistic Promises | 0.0 |
|
Operating Cash Flow vs Net Income Divergence
Paper profits without collected cash | Cash Flow Tracks Net Income Severe Negative Accrual Gap | 0.0 |
|
Industry Growth Deceleration & Commoditization
Structural decline in core margins | Secular Tailwinds Collapsing Margins & Obsolescence | 0.0 |
3. OPPORTUNITY & INTERNAL CONTROL WEAKNESSES
0 / 33 POINTS| Opportunity Metric | Diagnostic Slider (0 to 6.6 Points) | Score |
|---|---|---|
|
Complex / Opaque Corporate Vehicles (SPEs/VIEs)
Off-balance-sheet structures with limited visibility | Simple Plain Consolidated Books Hundreds of Cayman / BVI SPEs | 0.0 |
|
Subjective Mark-to-Market & Level 3 Assets
Valuations based on unobservable internal models | Liquid Quoted Market Securities Illiquid 20-Year Custom Swaps | 0.0 |
|
CEO / CFO Management Override Capabilities
Ability to post manual top-side journal entries | Strict Dual-Sign ERP Workflows Direct Top-Side Manual Journal Power | 0.0 |
|
Audit Committee Independence & Technical Literacy
Passive board members deferring to management | Former Big-4 Partners on Board Celebrity Insiders with Zero Accounting Fluency | 0.0 |
|
External Auditor Non-Audit Fee Conflicts
Consulting fees exceeding audit engagement fees | Zero Consulting Fees Consulting Fees Exceed Audit Fees | 0.0 |
4. RATIONALIZATION & CORPORATE ETHICAL CULTURE
0 / 34 POINTS| Rationalization Metric | Diagnostic Slider (0 to 6.8 Points) | Score |
|---|---|---|
|
Hostility Toward Regulatory Inquiries & Critics
Attacking short sellers, journalists, and auditors | Transparent Engagement Hostile Attacks & Defamation Lawsuits | 0.0 |
|
Tone at the Top & "Results by Any Means" Culture
Performance-or-termination corporate environment | Integrity Incentivized Rank-and-Yank Culture | 0.0 |
|
"Temporary Timing Gap" Rationalization
Belief that future revenue will cover past shortfalls | Rigid Accrual Cutoffs "We Are Just Borrowing from Q1" | 0.0 |
|
Executive Imperialism & Founder Hubris
Belief that standard rules do not apply to geniuses | Humble Accountable Leadership Messianic Founder Infallibility | 0.0 |
|
Industry Norm Rationalization ("Everyone Does It")
Belief that aggressive accounting is standard practice | Refuses Peer Bad Habits "Leveling the Playing Field" | 0.0 |
5. COMPOSITE FRAUD TRIANGLE SCORE & RADAR CHART
CALCULATED PROPENSITY|
TOTAL COMPOSITE RISK SCORE
0
/ 100
LOW FRAUD PROPENSITY
Pressure Subtotal: 0 / 33 Opportunity Subtotal: 0 / 33 Rationalization Subtotal: 0 / 34 | |