INTERACTIVE AUDIT INVESTIGATION

Forensic Audit Simulator: Spot the Cooked Books

Step into the shoes of a forensic investigator. Evaluate suspicious journal entries, executive excuses, and audit evidence across six historical fraud cases.

SIMULATOR BENCHMARKS
  • This interactive simulator tests your forensic skepticism against six authentic accounting manipulation scenarios from corporate history.
  • Forensic auditors must distinguish between legitimate commercial transactions, aggressive GAAP interpretations, and outright fraudulent fabrications.
  • Under Section 10A of the Securities Exchange Act, auditors who detect unaddressed illegal acts have a mandatory duty to notify the SEC Division of Enforcement.

INVESTIGATION SCOREBOARD

LIVE PERFORMANCE TRACKING
Metric Status / Score Assigned Forensic Rank Action
Audit Skepticism Score 0 / 600 Junior Staff Auditor (Deceived by Management)
0 of 6 Scenarios Completed

CASE 1: ZZZZ BEST CO., INC. (1986)

FICTITIOUS REVENUE & STAGED ASSETS
Investigation Field Details & Audit Workpapers
SITUATION You are the audit partner reviewing an $8.2M insurance restoration contract for a multi-story commercial complex in Sacramento. The client's CEO insists that you cannot contact the property owner or insurance adjuster directly due to contractual confidentiality clauses. However, he offers to personally fly you out and conduct a guided physical walkthrough of the ongoing restoration project.
AUDIT EVIDENCE Work order from Interstate Appraisal Services; invoice for $8.2M with 70% recognized revenue; walkthrough displays active workers, company banners, and building security guards greeting the CEO by name.
RESPONSE A
RESPONSE B
RESPONSE C

CASE 2: COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL (2000)

PREMATURE REVENUE RECOGNITION
Investigation Field Details & Audit Workpapers
SITUATION It is three days after the end of the fiscal quarter. The senior enterprise software sales executive approaches you with a $45M software licensing agreement from a major corporate customer. The contract signature is dated the final day of the quarter, but the email delivery timestamp and fax headers show it was executed two days after the quarter closed. Management asks you to approve recognition in the closed quarter.
AUDIT EVIDENCE Contract face date: March 31. Digital transmission metadata: April 2, 2:14 PM. General ledger is kept open by management decree under a practice colloquially called the '35-day month'.
RESPONSE A
RESPONSE B
RESPONSE C

CASE 3: WORLDCOM, INC. (2001)

CAPITALISING OPERATING EXPENSES
Investigation Field Details & Audit Workpapers
SITUATION During your review of fixed asset additions, you discover hundreds of manual top-level journal entries debiting Property, Plant & Equipment (Construction in Progress) and crediting Line Cost Operating Expenses for $850M. The entries lack work orders, vendor invoices, or engineering project numbers. CFO Scott Sullivan tells you these represent 'pre-paid capacity commitments for future anticipated network expansion.'
AUDIT EVIDENCE Manual journal entry: Debit PP&E (Construction in Progress) $850,000,000 / Credit Line Cost Expense $850,000,000. No project codes, engineering sign-offs, or contractor invoices attached.
RESPONSE A
RESPONSE B
RESPONSE C

CASE 4: REFCO INC. (2005)

ROUND-TRIPPING & DEBT CONCEALMENT
Investigation Field Details & Audit Workpapers
SITUATION Five days before fiscal year-end, the CEO's personal holding company wires $430M to the brokerage to fully pay off a long-standing related-party receivable. Three days after the fiscal year closes, Refco wires $430M back to an Austrian bank account tied to the CEO's holding company. Management states this was a routine short-term liquidity facility.
AUDIT EVIDENCE Wire receipt from RGHI: March 28 ($430M). Symmetrical outgoing wire: April 3 ($430M). Related-party balance is zero on balance sheet date but re-established immediately thereafter.
RESPONSE A
RESPONSE B
RESPONSE C

CASE 5: DIAMOND FOODS, INC. (2011)

DEFERRED COST ABUSE & PREPAID INFLATION
Investigation Field Details & Audit Workpapers
SITUATION During your review of cost of goods sold, you notice Diamond Foods paid $60M in supplemental payments to walnut growers for the autumn crop. Management has recorded these payments as 'momentum payments' capitalized under prepaid inventory for future crop years, rather than expensing them as current year walnut crop costs. Diamond is currently finalizing a stock acquisition of Pringles.
AUDIT EVIDENCE Grower agreement memos state payments represent 'advances on future supply', but interviews with growers reveal they view the checks as final payment for current crop deliveries.
RESPONSE A
RESPONSE B
RESPONSE C

CASE 6: PARMALAT FINANZIARIA (2003)

FICTITIOUS CASH & BANK CONFIRMATION FORGERY
Investigation Field Details & Audit Workpapers
SITUATION You are auditing Parmalat's Cayman Island financing subsidiary, Bonlat Financing Corp. The client provides a faxed copy of a Bank of America certificate confirming $4.9B in cash deposits. When you ask to send an electronic confirmation directly to Bank of America in Charlotte or Milan, management says Bonlat operates under Cayman private banking secrecy and that direct inquiries will violate local confidentiality laws.
AUDIT EVIDENCE Faxed letter on Bank of America stationery with blurred logos and mismatched typography. Address lists a post office box in Grand Cayman. Client refuses direct electronic bank verification.
RESPONSE A
RESPONSE B
RESPONSE C